The English auction

The Dutch auction



Online Auctions and Computer Mediated Communication (CMC)

Research

Dr. Avi Noy and Prof. Sheizaf Rafaeli

Graduate School of Business, The University of Haifa, Israel

 

October 2005


Recent information

21-Oct-2005 Results of our studies were published (see below).
10-Feb-2003 We are inviting intructors and groups to participate in the auction experiment. Please send me an email.

It is argued that the very first auction occurred thousands of years ago when Joseph of the Many-Colored Coat the son of Isaac was sold into slavery by his brothers. However the first generally accepted auctions occurred in Babylon in about 500 B.C. Auction has since spread around the world.

Among the basic auction mechanisms are:

1. Ascending-bid auctions.

2. Descending-bid auctions.

In ascending-bid auctions, the bidders raise the object’s price by providing higher and higher bids, until only a single bidder remains and the price paid is equal the last bid. This type of auction is “open” and the participants know the best current bid. There are many variants to this basic ascending-bid auctions.

In descending-bid auctions, the auctioneer starts with a high initial price and progressively lowers it. The price is posted and known to all participants. The first bidder to indicate a willingness to take the object at the prevailing price is the winner. There are also some variants to this type of descending-bid auctions.

During the last years, online implementations of auctions have become a prominent part of online systems. The emergence of online auctions in the Internet and Computer Mediated Communication (CMC) technologies created the basic motivation for our research.

We study the social process of auctions, as affected by the system design of its online implementation. Individual and group behavior of participants in online arrangements has become the focus of increasing study. Much of the focus has been on the psychological aspects of participants’ cognition, choices and actions. However, beyond the individual level of analysis, others influence online behavior as well. With the advent of online communication technologies, forums and contexts in addition to evidence that suggests that bidders may not enter auctions with fixed and immutable values, participants in online activities such as auctions, are more likely to be affected by the proximity and availability of others.

More attention needs to be paid to group and social-psychological inputs that may impact personal online behavior such as auctions. Our study turns attention to understanding behavior in online auctions from a social perspective. Namely, how can the design of online auction systems harness the expression of others’ presence to impact the behavior of individuals in online auctions?

We use computer simulation as our research tool. Until now, we developed two auction simulations:

- An ascending-bid “English” auction simulation

- A descending-bid “Dutch” auction simulation

These simulations are used in an experimental setting, which allowed varying levels of access and communication between auction participants.  The differential outcomes of participation under different levels of social interaction serve as a test of the various social-psychological theories.


 

Articles

Noy, A. and Rafaeli, S. (2005). Simulating Internet auctions online: Effects of learning and experience. International Journal of Simulation and Process Modeling,1(3/4), 161-170.

Rafaeli, S. and Noy, A. (2005). Social Presence: Influence on Bidders in Internet Auctions. EM-Electronic Markets, 15(2), 158-175.

Rafaeli, S., Raban, D. Ravid, G. and Noy, A. (2003). Online Simulations in Management Education about Information and its Uses. In C. Wankel and R. Defillipi (Eds.), Educating Managers with Tomorrow's Technologies A Volume in: Research in Management Education and Development, Information Age Publishing. pp. 53-80.

Rafaeli, S. and Noy, A. (2002). Online auctions, messaging, communication and social facilitation: a simulation and experimental evidence, European Journal of Information Systems, 11(3), 196-207.

Conference papers

Noy, A., Raban, D., and Ravid, G. (2005). Practicing What We Preach: Applying Theory to Game and Simulation         Development. Presented at ISAGA05, International Simulation and Gaming Association, Atlanta, Georgia USA.

Noy, A. (2004). Auction simulation as a research and teaching tool. Presented at Business Games Seminar, Haifa, Israel, Dec. 29, 2004.

Noy, A. (2004). The role of interpersonal information in electronic commerce: The case of Internet auctions. Presented at The Value of Information in Networked Contexts: An International Conference', Haifa, Israel, Feb 2-3, 2004.

Rafaeli, S. and Noy, A. (2002). Online Auctions, The presence of others in online auctions. Presented at the Association of Internet Research (AoIR): Internet Research 3.0: NET / WORK / THEORY, Maastricht, the Netherlands.

Rafaeli, S. and Noy, A. (2000). Social Interaction in Online Auctions: the case of Dutch Auctions. Presented at 'emotions' interdisciplinary conference, Oranim College, Israel.


This page is maintained by: Avi Noy
Last updated: 21-Oct-2003